The reason I decided to pay off my mortgage all at once.....

November 3, 2018

Payoff the mortgage or not? Always a big debate – especially for a real estate investor. I’ve always opted to have a mortgage on my primary residence because it was at a 4% rate. I can take the mortgage amount and own rental properties free and clear that yield a better return……so I thought!


Recently, one of the tenants in a property opted to buy the house they were in (lease to own). I owned the property free and clear so it was going to be a windfall of cash (a good thing but I had to have a plan as idle cash loses value).


Of course, I started to immediately scope out if there were any potential houses I could buy to make into rentals. First and foremost, I was surprised. I know the economy is strong. I see my IRA statements. I see my stock statements. I see my company’s sales and revenue. Yes, the economy is hot. But guess what? This affects real estate – it goes up in value. The amount of homes for sale is very minimal. And, those houses for sale are going for 20-30% higher than I was paying a few years ago. This made me pause and really dig into the option of using the proceeds from this sale to pay off my primary mortgage. When I did the math, it was a no brainer. This really surprised me. Here’s the math:




Sale of the rental property: $233,000


New potential rental houses: Approximately $130-135,000 (were $100-110K in 2014-2016)


Potential rent: $1100 per month per house


Primary house mortgage balance: $267,000 (I would have to tap into my savings of $34,000 to pay off)


Basically for $267K, I could buy two rental houses and collect $2200 per month (gross return of 9.9%)


If I paid off my mortgage, I would free up $1356 cash each month (essentially gross 6.1% return)


If I only stopped there, better to buy 2 rental houses for $267K than pay off my mortgage. BUT, these are gross returns. I delved deeper factoring in expense on rentals and interest savings on mortgage. This changes it!


Rental Home Option


Investment: $267K (2 houses)


Rental income: $1100 x 2 (per month)


Expenses (annual) : Property taxes ($1100 x 2); Insurance ($650 x 2); Maintenance ($1200 x 2); Income tax ($2700 total)


Annual profit: $17,800 (net return of 6.7%)


Pay off mortgage option


Investment: $267K (mortgage balance)


Monthly mortgage payment: $1356 ($875 of which is interest)


Note: I plan to sell my house in 6 years and downsize. This is important as it makes the interest on the mortgage very real in terms of cash in 6 years when I sell. (If I keep the mortgage until I sell in 2024, I pay additional $63K ($875 x 72), ouch)


Net monthly cash: $1356 (monthly payment) plus the $875 savings in interest = $2231


Annual “profit”: $2231 x 12 = $26,772 (net return of 10.0%)


And, I don’t have to deal with maintenance on 2 houses vs. maintenance on my own house plus tenant issues. This has some value.


In the end, the option to pay off my primary residence was a no-brainer vs. buying 2 rental properties. 6.7% vs. 10.0% (annual net cash difference of $26,772 - $17,800 = $8972). The 4% mortgage interest rate is deceiving because mortgages are front loaded with interest – this is a BIG deal. The bank gets theirs upfront, screwing you the mortgagee.


I did pay off my mortgage in early April. Last week I got the lien release and deed. This month, it was very cool NOT to send a mortgage payment to the Credit Union. What did I do with that cash? Invested it of course! (See my post on the Boiled Frog Syndrome)

Please reload

Recent Posts

December 18, 2017

Please reload


Please reload


I'm busy working on my blog posts. Watch this space!

Please reload

Indianapolis, Indiana


This site was designed with the
website builder. Create your website today.
Start Now